a word about thickness and wondersteels....
powdered metal may show fine in an engineer designed test for structural elements, as for notch test and etc.
But, that is not knife use, and powdered metals generally chip and break edges and tips when stressed. They are no manner of spring, once the stuff starts to flex, all bets are off. And they are very stiff, and resist that flex...to a point.
So, a hard use knife of the stuff, where its main advantage is edge retention in controlled cutting of abrasive substances, needs to be stout. Stout as in edge and tip, to resist, as well as possible, that flex which leads to failure mode.
So, Rick has the recipe correct, as for powdered stainless use. The best steel for such a hard use knife would be in the 80CrV2 class with salt bath, second choice 5160...
..but everybody wants stainless. So, we are back to square one, and better make it stout and poorer knife, rather than lose edge or tip.
Complete thread:
- Purdy by yimminy tough, you betcha, fer sure... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 19:47
- Purdy by yimminy tough, you betcha, fer sure... -
bj,
2018-06-23, 20:05
- sure, folk can say just carry a fixed blade.... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 21:39
- the main advantage of the fixed blade.... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 10:53
- As for the owner, anyone who watches shop videos -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 21:58
- Rick's target market has always been military, - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 13:49
- as for cutter, these knives are designed to -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 22:26
- This particular blade style is the least cuttin'est.. - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 00:31
- In the ZT comparison, the ZT is a thinner blade, -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 22:36
- for further comparisons... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 02:39
- in further ZT comparison, sort... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 10:47
- it's not only the blade thickness -
bj,
2018-06-24, 18:58
- exactly, and thick edge for toughness....thin chips/breaks, - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 20:14
- a word about thickness and wondersteels.... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 17:00
- a word about thickness and wondersteels.... -
bj,
2018-06-24, 19:11
- Nope, am talking about how powdered metal -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 20:11
- Nope, am talking about how powdered metal -
bj,
2018-06-24, 23:41
- BJ, you have a wonderful technical vocabulary -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 00:29
- and not wishing ANY particle sintered steel shorted, -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 00:46
- Interesting and entertaining discussion -
Catoosa,
2018-06-25, 10:38
- i am wit chu, boss.... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 12:54
- anyhow, i hope you enjoyed the show-n-tell.... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-26, 19:28
- i am wit chu, boss.... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 12:54
- Interesting and entertaining discussion -
Catoosa,
2018-06-25, 10:38
- BJ, you have a wonderful technical vocabulary -
bj,
2018-06-25, 21:54
- Look...this place was near deader than a dodo for a few days -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-26, 23:46
- and, quite frankly, considering the several times, -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-27, 00:07
- I've enjoyed reading your treatise... - pokynojoe, 2018-06-27, 08:19
- Look...this place was near deader than a dodo for a few days - bj, 2018-06-27, 19:48
- and, quite frankly, considering the several times, -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-27, 00:07
- Look...this place was near deader than a dodo for a few days -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-26, 23:46
- and not wishing ANY particle sintered steel shorted, -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 00:46
- BJ, you have a wonderful technical vocabulary -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-25, 00:29
- Nope, am talking about how powdered metal -
bj,
2018-06-24, 23:41
- Nope, am talking about how powdered metal -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 20:11
- a word about thickness and wondersteels.... -
bj,
2018-06-24, 19:11
- and, a word about carry... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 17:41
- a word about thrust bearings aka washers.... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-25, 16:24
- And, a word about edging/sharpening.... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-25, 17:16
- sure, folk can say just carry a fixed blade.... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-23, 21:39
- Purdy by yimminy tough, you betcha, fer sure... -
ERSisk,
2018-06-24, 11:28
- The handle is all kinda big and roomy... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 13:34
- as to big and roomy.... - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-24, 14:34
- still waiting on the 10mm review....nt -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 16:48
- still waiting on the 10mm review....nt -
ERSisk,
2018-06-25, 08:08
- flooring......eeek!.....nt - former hater of plastic, 2018-06-25, 12:58
- still waiting on the 10mm review....nt -
ERSisk,
2018-06-25, 08:08
- The handle is all kinda big and roomy... -
former hater of plastic,
2018-06-24, 13:34
- Purdy by yimminy tough, you betcha, fer sure... -
bj,
2018-06-23, 20:05