They compiled Police one shot stops...
Their data was so offensive to so many it ended both their writing careers. I know Evan and he still carries a 41 mag, .357 SIG or 9mm with a .357 J frame. 
There is some reasoned conjecture that since many of the one shot stops with a .357 mag were in low lit areas/after dark, many of the "one shot stops" were as much psychological and physical. Even though the fight was stopped there was a better than 50% survival rate for the perpetrator.  
Shot placement is far more important.
--
Of the Troops & For the Troops
Complete thread:
- Comparisons - 
JimT, 
2024-01-05, 17:58 ![Open whole thread [*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png)  - "...full of sound and fury, signifying nothing" - 
JohnKDM, 
2024-01-05, 18:05
- "...full of sound and fury, signifying nothing" - JimT, 2024-01-05, 18:10
 
- Firing a little 50,000 psi pistol sounds scary. no text - 
Bob Hatfield, 
2024-01-06, 11:03
- TRUE! . no text - JimT, 2024-01-06, 11:16
 
- Comparisons - 
A K Church, 
2024-01-06, 16:06
- Who was the guy that promoted the .357 as 'ultimate' .. - 
JimT, 
2024-01-06, 17:33
- Who was the guy that promoted the .357 as 'ultimate' .. - 
A K Church, 
2024-01-06, 20:13
- YES ... they are the ones. (nt) - JimT, 2024-01-06, 20:29
- They compiled Police one shot stops... - Rob Leahy, 2024-01-10, 09:29
 
- Too much SNAP for my preference... - 
Paul, 
2024-01-06, 20:19
- I've still never seen a 30 Super Carry, - Miles, 2024-01-07, 03:04
 
 
- Who was the guy that promoted the .357 as 'ultimate' .. - 
A K Church, 
2024-01-06, 20:13
 
- Who was the guy that promoted the .357 as 'ultimate' .. - 
JimT, 
2024-01-06, 17:33
 
- "...full of sound and fury, signifying nothing" - 
JohnKDM, 
2024-01-05, 18:05

