"Texas Rising"

by Drago, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 00:12 (3404 days ago)

What say ye Texans?

Entertaining with major points at least touched on

by MR, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 10:13 (3404 days ago) @ Drago

I'm going to say there's a lot of dramatic license in the details. Before I would pass final judgement on it on other as entertainment, I would like to have stack reader privlidges and a few days in the locked-white gloves requried areas in the libraries at TAMU and UT.

Ptooey...

by JLF @, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 10:54 (3404 days ago) @ Drago

Just bloody awful, so awful that I don't even know where to start. The Texas revolution was fought east of I-35, in rolling green farm and pastureland, interspersed with areas of dense forest. There was no "cowboy" desert, with vast cliffs and scenic views, only in the minds of Hollywood screenwriters. I kept expecting the Apaches to attack.

The Alamo had exactly *two* Black people, a volunteer's concubine, who was killed in the fighting, and W.B. Travis' personal slave, who Santa Ana spared to demonstrate his racial liberalism. Emily West, if she even did exist, was never anywhere near the Alamo, and had nothing to do with Houston, or the army.

Deaf Smith had *nothing* to do with the Texas Rangers, nothing of which even remotely existed until well after the Republic was formed. The thinking behind the Rangers, and their name, was of English origins, not Mexican.

That's just the high points. I've watched two episodes, but I fear the battle of San Jacinto may put my little TV in too much danger. No doubt it will be fought in the desert among towering cliffs, with Sterling Haden hoping the US calvary shows up in time to save them from the Apaches...

JLF

"with Sterling Haden hoping the US calvary shows up"

by cas, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 11:25 (3404 days ago) @ JLF
edited by cas, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 11:28

Now THAT would be a twist, considering. :-D

BTW it was filmed in Durango, Mexico

by MR, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 12:32 (3404 days ago) @ JLF

The last thing I saw come out of the film industry that I thought was remotely accurate in place of just trying to sell advertiser time was Tora Tora Tora.

At least they got the Deguello as an actual bugle call rather than a melodic love ballad this time.

The biggest absurdity for me

by BC, IA, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 13:03 (3404 days ago) @ JLF

is how the Deaf Smith character appears at multiple locations from scene to scene, including stopping at home for a quickie with his wife and a bit of gardening, all while rescuing orphans and stray dogs.

The dialog is worse than awful. Somehow I just knew that someone was going to exclaim "when you cut off the head of the snake, the body dies". I just didn't realize how quickly they would shoot that silver bullet.

The two dopey Junior Rangers were possibly the worst characters of the bunch. Their inclusion smacked of rotten cheese.

I kept comparing it to the silly/ridiculous Made For TV westerns and mini-series of the mid-70s to mid-80s. In truth, if that is what the network and producers were going for, they nailed it. They just need more feathered hair styles and muzak.

Ptooey...

by Boge Quinn, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 14:15 (3404 days ago) @ JLF

I had the highest of hopes, but couldn't get through the first episode.

Ptooey...

by MR, Sunday, May 31, 2015, 22:21 (3404 days ago) @ JLF

Ptooey...

by uncowboy, Monday, June 01, 2015, 11:36 (3403 days ago) @ MR

I am let down by it.

we barely made through one episode

by bj @, Monday, June 01, 2015, 22:13 (3403 days ago) @ JLF

and knew better than to try watching any more

THEY LABEL IT IN THE BEGINNING AS

by SIXGUNNER, Wednesday, June 03, 2015, 07:59 (3401 days ago) @ JLF

DRAMATIC NOT HISTORIC. DON'T EVER EXPECT TO LEARN HISTORY FROM "HISTORIC MOVIES".

And you were expecting what?

by Charles, Friday, June 05, 2015, 08:49 (3399 days ago) @ Drago
edited by Charles, Friday, June 05, 2015, 08:54

Certainly not a historically accurate account of Texas Independence. Lonesome Dove was fiction loosely based on the lives of Oliver Loving and Charles Goodnight. Texas Rising is fiction loosely based on the events and people involved in Texas Independence.

There are things I am grateful for;

1. Santa Anna is shown as the cruel despot he was.
2. The Comanche are shown as the murdering raiders of homesteads they were.
3. Texans are shown as Americans in search of freedom from a despotic government as they were.

There are things I really don't like;

Jack Hays and Bigfoot Wallace are shown as bumbling hapless cartoon characters and they were certainly not that.

The story of Emily West/Morgan is all twisted up and entirely wrong.

Taken as a whole it is about a C+ fictional drama.

No sense boys getting spun up about it not being what it was never intended to be.

RSS Feed of thread

powered by my little forum