How about another AR question...free float vs. standard

by rob , Thursday, April 23, 2015, 12:53 (3506 days ago)

I'd talk about sixguns and leverguns but I've got that pretty much down:) I'd like to free float my barrel but I'm not sure it's worth it. My carbine already shoots from slightly below MOA to slightly over with a decent selection of loads with MX193 usually going about 1.5-1.75". I don't like the bulky quad rails. I do kinda like the slim Midwest Industries rail. But, overall, I still can't get past the idea that the good old Milspec hand guard is simple, reliable and not exactly prone to variables like screws coming loose, etc. And, after all, if it shoots most hunting loads under an inch and 55 grain 5.56 under 2" at 100 yards, how much better do I need? I keep thinking I'd like to build an SPR upper but regardless, it's still pretty much a 300 yard rifle max. If I want that I'd just as soon grab my '06. So I'm leaning toward just popping a good Magpul MOE hand guard on it instead of a free float rail. If I do go with a free float rail it has to be tough. I don't want anything flimsy on a fighting rifle. Opinions?