Sarge, Question on Sig P220...

by rob @, Saturday, March 02, 2013, 20:25 (4287 days ago)

I just read your article on the P220. My Carry model throws the brass well into the grass at the shooting range about three to four feet in front and about seven feet right. Has this been your experience with yours? It's the ONLY thing about my Sig that doesn't give me the giddies! I wonder if anything can be done to tweak it without affecting reliability?

rob

I've owned 3 P220's and a P245, internal and external...

by cas, Saturday, March 02, 2013, 22:55 (4286 days ago) @ rob

...extractors. I don't remember any of them throwing brass forward.

Hmmm… Is it new?

Sarge, Question on Sig P220...

by Sarge ⌂ @, Central Misery, Sunday, March 03, 2013, 07:36 (4286 days ago) @ rob

I do recall mine tossing brass well to the side and perhaps slightly toward the muzzle, particularly with full power JHP loads. This changed a tad when I ran a 24 lb recoil spring with some 450 Triton (basically an early 45 Super) I shot a few rounds of. My suggestion would be to play with spring weights and leave the gun alone otherwise.

Gen 4 Glocks have developed a reputation for delivering hot brass to the face, and this came up at the last Armorer school I attended. As the Glock rep said, in so many words, "The object of the ejection cycle is to clear the action of the fired case. All else is incidental." My poor old G23 apparently considers fired brass disposable, like a Bic lighter. I shoot in a hay field at home, so kiss it goodbye. I'm going to shoot in the snow today, so I can at least establish what zip code I need to search ;)

Glad you enjoyed the 220 article.

Sarge, Question on Sig P220...

by rob @, Sunday, March 03, 2013, 08:15 (4286 days ago) @ Sarge

My Gen4 21 drops them somewhere between at my feet or slightly behind me and to the right, even with stout loads. I do like that. Seems the Gen4 springs are heavier maybe. I'd kinda like to have a spare P220 and this one is great but I see horror stories all over the web about Sig's customer service and the guns not being as good as they used to be...QC & MIM parts and such. I've had three failures to fire on single action but fired when the trigger was pulled again. Looked at the first one and no firing pin strike. I can't get it to not hit a pencil, eracer end first, ever, and it only did it with handloads so I may have those crimped to tight and they were clambering to deep. That's my best guess anyhow. Other than that its been perfect with factory loads.

Mine has the 3.9" barrel...

by rob @, Sunday, March 03, 2013, 08:19 (4286 days ago) @ Sarge

I'd kinda like one of the 4.4"'s but I'm not sure what .5" of barrel will really benefit me:)

Sarge, Question on Sig P220...

by Charles, Sunday, March 03, 2013, 13:05 (4286 days ago) @ rob

I am not Sarge, but I am a fan of the Sig P220. I have paid no attention to where it throws brass and that is a non-issue with me. On a social handgun, I want the brass as far away from me and it can pitch em. I don't want to be steping on my brass if I have to move sidways. I want level ground under my feet as much as that is possible. It could throw the brass into the next county and that would be fine with me.

I agree Charles...

by rob @, Sunday, March 03, 2013, 13:54 (4286 days ago) @ Charles

I just want it thrown behind me instead of down range where I can't gather my brass without shutting down the range.

RSS Feed of thread

powered by my little forum